Jump to content

Photo

Klde Vs Klg4 Vs Klze


  • Please log in to reply
68 replies to this topic

#1
itsamecameron

itsamecameron

    Newbie

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 14 posts
  • Car: 1998 626 LX V6 auto
KLDE vs KLG4 vs KLZE




Hi all new to the forums but have been doing research for quite a while. I have learned quite a bit through the various forums such as www.mx6.com www.probetalk.com and this very site. I would like to thank anyone that posts more info to this thread!! I will update all info to this first post to keep things simple to find. I have noticed a general trend that many of us are confused about our motors and what differences there are from year to year, j-spec ect. (I know I was!!) My goal here is to list basic specs for the three KL variations, differences between each one, and clear up common misconceptions in regards to compatibility and benefits of parts between the three. I have found all the information from the above sites and credit should be given to the above forums and their members. That includes members of this forum that add to the thread!! ;) If any corrections or additions need to be made go ahead and let me know! I love to have accurate info and am happy to hear what others have to say.

First off there are three main variations of the KL series motors that we will be working with... the KLDE, KLG4, and KLZE respectively. They are all 2.5L DOHC V-6 with 4 valves per cylinder, and where available in the Mazda 626, Mazda MX-6, Ford Probe, and other cars not sold in the U.S. The KL series was available in 1993 all the way up to 2002 in the U.S. The KL series lived longer outside the states, when/if production quit I am not sure.

KLDE (1993-1997) U.S.

  • 164 horse power with 156 ft/lb torque
  • Compression ratio of 9.2:1
  • 84.5 mm bore, 74.2 mm stroke
  • Uses OBD-I through 1995
  • 1996-1997 OBD-II
  • 220cc Fuel injectors
If you have a stock 1993-1997 Probe GT, 626 V6, or an MX-6 V6 you have a KLDE.

  • A common upgrade is to swap the stock intake manifold with a KLZE manifold. The DE manifold has oval intake runners while the ZE has square runners, so port matching is a must for best results. Also the ZE has no place for an EGR valve so if you live in a state with emissions testing or are annoyed by the CEL being on constantly this may not be the route for you. A good alternative would be to get a KLG4 manifold to swap. With proper porting and knife edging the gains will be about the same, but the runners are the same shape and it has an EGR valve. This makes it a simple swap.
  • The DE uses a VAF which can be very restrictive compared to a MAF
  • The KLDE uses a distributor cap. This has its ups and downs, but be aware that the distributor is driven by a gear with the cam shaft, so any swaps will need to have this gear. The cam shafts use whats called a Hydraulic Lash Adjuster or HLA for short. The HLA can cause many headaches with the car so be aware if you hear em tapping.
  • The DE uses OBD-I and has some ECU upgrade options.
  • Generally a KLDE will put out less power than a KLZE running similar components with the same amount of boost
  • From what I can gather the recommended boost pressure is about 6psi, although I have heard of a daily driver pushing 15psi for about 7 months on stock internals.
  • The KLDE uses better stock retainers than a KLZE


KLG4 (1998-2002) U.S.

  • 170 horse power with 163 ft/lb torque
  • Compression ratio of 9.5:1
  • 84.6 mm bore, 74.2 mm stroke
  • Uses OBD-II
  • 220cc Injectors
If you have a stock 1998-2002 626 then you have the KLG4. People commonly mistake this motor for the KLDE, while there are many similarities there are also many differences. The KLG4 is the last revision in the KL series. Many issues that plague the DE are resolved by the G4. Power wise it is in between the KLDE and KLZE.

  • The KLG4 was introduced in 1998 so needless to say you won't find a stock MX-6 or Probe with one in it.
  • The G4 uses an electronic coil pack system instead of a distributor cap.
  • The G4 uses better solid lifters as opposed to the HLA system in previous models.
  • The G4 uses a MAF sensor for better intake flow and more accurate readings.
  • The KLG4 has the lightest crank out of the three variations (I believe about 7 lbs lighter) this reduces rotating mass...its a good thing.
  • The G4 is OBD-II only
  • Most parts/upgrades for the KLDE will bolt right up to the KLG4
  • The power band of the G4 is shifted slightly to the right compared to the DE
  • As far as I can find the ECU in the G4 is un-tweakable...
  • The KLG4 can handle boost with stock internals best out of the three variations (according to members on the forums anyway) , that is it will be least likely to be damaged due to boost when compared to a DE or ZE with the same pressure under the same conditions...think apples to apples..


KLZE (J-Spec)

I want to start off by saying that there is a lack of concrete information in regards to the KLZE. With that in mind I will present the info that I have found...

  • The KLZE is said to have anywhere from 190 horse power all the way up to just over 200 horse power.
  • Torque is in the area of 165+ ft/lbs
  • Uses more aggressive cams that allow for longer lift durations.
  • Has a compression ratio of 10.0:1
  • Can be put into any V6 626 with little modification (as long as you use all of your current sensors and ECU)
  • Said to be best bang for buck when power is concerned
  • Has NO EGR valve so to prevent a CEL the EGR should be left plugged in to vacuum lines and electrical connection...
  • Mods to first generation DE ECUs can be made to take further advantage of the cams
  • There are two variants available, a straight neck and a curved neck. (Straight neck is usually more spendy but better, curved necks are often used in MX-3s due to smaller engine bay)
  • There are curved neck ZEs that have standard compression pistons, and standard compression cams! So be sure to get a look at the stamp on the cams if you are considering a ZE. Thanks to MonoxideChild for the info on that!
  • They will produce more power with lower amounts of boost due to the higher compression ratio ( this also makes them run a higher risk of internal damage)
  • An after market air intake should be used since the stock DE and G4 intake box will mount up properly. (Not sure if this is fact or fiction since I have not had a ZE)
  • In a nutshell the extra power comes from higher compression pistons, different intake manifold, and more aggressive cam shafts.
  • KLZE uses the same 220cc fuel injectors as the DE and G4
Interchangeable parts between the three (Make your own KL hybrid variation!)
Intake manifold (use the best one for your application)
Transmissions (any KL, KF, K8, and KJ use the same bell housing! )
The block
Rods pistons bearings ect...
Injectors (Millenia S or JE injectors are a good upgrade @ 280cc and a direct fit)



Some fuzzy areas that I need help clearing up:

I don't know is weather the ZE or the G4 intake manifold flows better. Seems like everyone has their own opinion with no info to back it.... I have come to the general understanding that either will flow better than the stock DE IM... so if you have any info on this lets hear it!!

I know the DE and G4 are non-interference motors. I would assume that the ZE IS an interference motor due to the flat top pistons.... but im not sure.

I can't seem to find if removing/bypassing the EGR valve will result in a power gain or not.... I know it can be done, and there are work arounds for the CEL but I just can't see why people are doing it...

From what ive read, the DE and ZE use distributors and are driven by a cam gear... so that would lead me to believe that you cant swap cams from a DE/ZE into a G4 and vice versa




Thats all I can think of right now, but if anyone has additions feel free to post em up!

#2
MonoxideChild

MonoxideChild

    Veteran

  • Moderator
  • 6,599 posts
  • Location: RockFord,IL
  • Car: you name it, i own it...
there are also ODB-II KLDE's. 95 is the crossover year, then 96-97's are ODB-II.

the KLG4 does indeed have the lighter crank. the center counter balance on the crank is just not there on the G4's. not many know about the different cranks. surprised to actually even see it mentioned. lol

there are also curved neck ZE's. which do not have the 10-1 compression, or the ZE cams. (its pretty much a American spec millenia motor, but without a EGR)

you can use a milly, or de manifold on the ZE block. there's no reason it wont fit.

when it comes to the KLG4 vs KLZE heads, pic which ever head you have. if you have a oval port head, use the G4, if its a square port, use the ZE mani.

all use the same bell housing. also the same as the K8, KF, and even KJ


you should add info on the millenia also. thats another great source for motors. and usually the one i try to grab before a KLDE out of a probe/mx6.


great read and info though! thanks for the thread. sure alot of people will get alot from it! :)

#3
itsamecameron

itsamecameron

    Newbie

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 14 posts
  • Car: 1998 626 LX V6 auto
Ah I completely forgot about the Millenia!! Well now I have another bit of searching to do. Not sure why but whenever I think of the Millenia I always think of the 2.3 Miller cycle.... love the way that motor sounds! Speaking of the Millenia S im pretty sure we can use the fuel rails off of em... Could be a cheap injector upgrade if one was at a junk yard.


Oh and I updated the info, thanks for the help

#4
MonoxideChild

MonoxideChild

    Veteran

  • Moderator
  • 6,599 posts
  • Location: RockFord,IL
  • Car: you name it, i own it...
Yup. The milly S injectors are probably the most common injector used as an upgrade. Th older mazda JE used the same ones also. And can be found a bit easier too.

#5
XeNoMoRpH

XeNoMoRpH

    Mazda 626.net

  • Admin
  • 5,592 posts
  • Location: Virginia
  • Car: 1988 626 GT ----- 1995 MX-6 LS

Yup. The milly S injectors are probably the most common injector used as an upgrade. Th older mazda JE used the same ones also. And can be found a bit easier too.


I knew about the Millenia S, but not the Mazda JE, which if anyone cares could be in the 3rd and 4th generation 929 and 1st generation MPV (according to Wikipedia).

Lots of good information on this post. One thing though, when it comes to the compression ratios there are a lot of different numbers thrown around. I learned the KLDE and KLG4 were around 10:1 while the ZE was 11:1. Which ones are correct?

#6
MonoxideChild

MonoxideChild

    Veteran

  • Moderator
  • 6,599 posts
  • Location: RockFord,IL
  • Car: you name it, i own it...
Off memory. klde is 9.2.1. Milly and klg4 is 9.5.1. And the ze is 10.1. curved nEck ze's are the lower 9.5.1 compression like i mentioned earlier though

#7
itsamecameron

itsamecameron

    Newbie

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 14 posts
  • Car: 1998 626 LX V6 auto
yup the two a spec motor specs where verified via http://www.interneta....com/index.html it's a good un bias souce for that info

#8
PrinceValorum

PrinceValorum

    Veteran

  • Moderator
  • 6,952 posts
  • Location: NE Ohio
  • Car: 06 MS6 GT, 03 P5 KLZE swap (ish)
For future reference, it's possible to build an engine using some parts from all of these motors that would put out the same power as a ZE, but still have the EGR for emissions? I like the lightweight crank from the G4, the beefier valves and springs from the DE head, and the ZE cams and pistons. People have at least claimed that a ported DE mani will flow more than the ZE, plus it has the EGR. There were some dyno plots on PT, too from a Russian member. This is really cool to get all of the info in one place.

#9
itsamecameron

itsamecameron

    Newbie

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 14 posts
  • Car: 1998 626 LX V6 auto

For future reference, it's possible to build an engine using some parts from all of these motors that would put out the same power as a ZE, but still have the EGR for emissions? I like the lightweight crank from the G4, the beefier valves and springs from the DE head, and the ZE cams and pistons. People have at least claimed that a ported DE mani will flow more than the ZE, plus it has the EGR. There were some dyno plots on PT, too from a Russian member. This is really cool to get all of the info in one place.


That is great to hear that there are actual dyno plots! I may have to track the thread down and post a link.. So the DE has better valves and springs?? I have never heard that, but a good bit of info to add to the thread. I really want to put as much solid info I can find into the thread. There are just way too many rumors floating around about the KL series in general, so it makes it super hard to find more info that is fact! I am currently looking into the Milly motors... once I sort through all the stuff and find good solid info ill be sure to post it up. If I posted all the info ive found that was not backed or the "my buddy has a... and he says it..." stuff this thread would be much longer lol.

Also just want to throw this out there, I will copy some of the info out of ur posts and update the first one.. If you don't want me to do that just let me know!! I want to keep it simple to look at and find the info instead of going through many posts for one tid bit of info. I DONT want to take credit for any of the info, since its not my info to start with, I am just tryin to sort it out and arrange it in one place.

Thanks for all the added info guys, and keep it coming!

#10
MonoxideChild

MonoxideChild

    Veteran

  • Moderator
  • 6,599 posts
  • Location: RockFord,IL
  • Car: you name it, i own it...
its mainly the DE retainers. the ZE's have a tendency to break when pushed to higher RPM's.

#11
PrinceValorum

PrinceValorum

    Veteran

  • Moderator
  • 6,952 posts
  • Location: NE Ohio
  • Car: 06 MS6 GT, 03 P5 KLZE swap (ish)
^^Okay, good to know!

Alright, I found the dyno plot on PT. It was a bit buried in the photo section. I read through most of the thread before, and there was a appreciable difference between the ported heads of the DE and ZE. What I'm gathering from the first two graphs is that the ZE head had to be improved but still running the stock valves to match the DE head stock.
http://forums.probet...hp?t=1701283032

#12
XeNoMoRpH

XeNoMoRpH

    Mazda 626.net

  • Admin
  • 5,592 posts
  • Location: Virginia
  • Car: 1988 626 GT ----- 1995 MX-6 LS
That's good info. So, you should be able to make a KL with over 200hp by using different parts from all three?

#13
PrinceValorum

PrinceValorum

    Veteran

  • Moderator
  • 6,952 posts
  • Location: NE Ohio
  • Car: 06 MS6 GT, 03 P5 KLZE swap (ish)

That's good info. So, you should be able to make a KL with over 200hp by using different parts from all three?


Yeah, that's what it looks like. I can't remember where I read it, but I remember reading in a thread somewhere that there were some KL's used for some race series that were making over 400hp NA... I haven't heard of anyone else making anywhere close to that kind of power, so I'm not sure if it's even possible, and if it is, I have no idea what their secret is. There's too much of that "I've heard" info about these engines, as itsamecameron said.

I want to know if it's possible to build a 200+hp KL that can pass emissions. I live in one of those unlucky areas that "cares" and I'm not in a position to move for a few years. Down the road, that will definitely affect where I live.

I also found this thread on PT demonstrating the clearly visible difference in DE and ZE power. The vids in the first post are awesome, but the thread goes downhill quickly.
http://forums.probet...hp?t=1701290017

#14
XeNoMoRpH

XeNoMoRpH

    Mazda 626.net

  • Admin
  • 5,592 posts
  • Location: Virginia
  • Car: 1988 626 GT ----- 1995 MX-6 LS
This seems like the ideal engine then:

KLG4 as the base.
KLDE valves/retainers
KLZE camshaft, pistons, connecting rods maybe?

I suppose it really doesn't matter which is the "base", I simply went with the KLG4 because that's what I have and it has solid lifters meaning more power. Is there any different between the DE and G4 intake manifolds?

#15
itsamecameron

itsamecameron

    Newbie

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 14 posts
  • Car: 1998 626 LX V6 auto

This seems like the ideal engine then:

KLG4 as the base.
KLDE valves/retainers
KLZE camshaft, pistons, connecting rods maybe?

I suppose it really doesn't matter which is the "base", I simply went with the KLG4 because that's what I have and it has solid lifters meaning more power. Is there any different between the DE and G4 intake manifolds?


Yeah there are differences between the manifolds. The G4 is the best flowing manifold that has an EGR valve. VRIS is a little different in the G4 but it should work with a DE just fine. I have a G4 and am just going to port it and add pheno spacers... If you have a G4 I really don't think its worth the money and time involved to get it going the "right" way. (You really should port match it so you are not going from a rectangle to an oval..)
Also there IS a device that is not made anymore that allows you to adjust the VRIS points... So if you are running a mixture of parts you can do a dyno run and find the best settings to adjust...

http://www.thevenom....rs/vrtuner.html

It would be great if they told us how to build one, since they are not building any or selling any... I know id build one just to try it out

Just in case you want to know here is what your VRIS does for you! VRISdiagram.jpg


Just so you know the time and money involved to get said parts would be quite a bit... and its well known that the KL has weak rods, so I would personally go aftermarket on the rods and pistons (which you can get in high and low compression). Stick with the block and IM that you have, ZE cams are great until you realize they are not that much less than a complete ZE... especially since you can get EVEN MORE aggressive race ground cams...

The ZE is a good engine but its still stock... So improvements can be made in many places... unfortunately most of those places are the same as a DE G4...

Just a swap to have the higher NA power is great, but doing a ZE swap just to replace some of the parts that make it a ZE sounds redundant to me...

Here is what my ideal engine list would be

KLG4 base
Ported and knife edged IM
Pheno spacers
Ported TB
Ground and knife edge throttle plate & VRIS shutters
Aftermarket rods, and pistons (NA high compression, boost low compression)
Race ground camshafts
KLG4 ignition system
Milly S fuel injection
Be sure to get a good CAI, Exhaust headers, and exhaust system
Good plugs and wires....




1 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users


    Google (1)